iCloud storage often becomes a contentious issue for iPhone users who wish to avoid monthly fees for cloud services while finding the complimentary 5GB plan insufficient. Recently, Apple successfully overcame a lawsuit in the U.S. regarding its iCloud storage strategy, as a judge dismissed the case.
Judge dismisses lawsuit after claims against Apple ruled to lack merit
Mike Scarcella reports for Reuters:
Apple secured a favorable ruling that dismissed allegations of illegally monopolizing the digital storage market, which purportedly resulted in higher prices for iCloud services.
U.S. District Judge Eumi Lee, based in San Jose, California, stated on Friday that the plaintiffs in the class action failed to demonstrate that Apple had breached federal or state antitrust laws. Nevertheless, she allowed them the opportunity to revise their complaint and resubmit it.
The lawsuit claimed Apple violated antitrust laws by compelling users to utilize its iCloud service for backing up essential data and device settings. Apple has consistently denied any misconduct.
Plaintiffs contended that Apple possesses a monopoly on cloud storage for its devices, since no other services offer the functionalities necessary for tasks like restoring an iPhone. Consequently, they accused Apple of artificially inflating its iCloud storage prices.
In her dismissal of the lawsuit, Judge Lee expressed skepticism regarding the plaintiffs’ assertions. She remarked, “if anything, Apple’s allegedly high prices would motivate competitors to boost production and capture market share from Apple.”
The judge also rejected the characterization that purchasing iCloud storage is essential for users, or that Apple demonstrated monopoly-like dominance in the cloud storage arena.
My key takeaway from this lawsuit: Apple’s 5GB iCloud storage plan is unlikely to change in the near future, nor are its paid storage packages.
What are your thoughts on the ruling regarding the iCloud storage lawsuit? Share your opinions in the comments below.
